Canadian officers say women warriors proved as effective as men in front-line combat roles in Ottawa's most recent big military engagement, in Afghanistan from 2002 to 2011. But Canada has struggled to fill combat jobs with women, and those who do join can feel isolated as a result. And like Cpl. Moman, many of the women who volunteered for these jobs got the impression that their senior officers used them only sparingly in combat. Proponents argue that it will help the military retain more women, who tend to leave the services permanently when they have children. Opponents argue that allowing women to serve in these roles would limit the military's ability to fight in combat situations.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Province/Territory:
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How would you feel if someone close to you wanted to join the military and serve in a combat role?
@9XHQN822yrs2Y
I feel that is their right, and anyone who wants to sign up to fight the governments' fights for them should be able to.
@9X4XJVH2yrs2Y
i believe they have the right to choose what they want to do while risking there lives.
@9WXF8RTNew Democratic2yrs2Y
Anyone should be able to freely choose to sell their body to the government and die in imperialist wars
@9WL6S5Y2yrs2Y
There should be a mandatory physical and mental test to complete in order to serve in combat and gender should not be an issue.
@4VTK4QQ6yrs6Y
men and women in a group = couples
@9J4QTKJConservative2yrs2Y
Yes, women are able to be as strong as men. There should be a promotion in the target audience for women to serve. There should be sexual assault provention programs and other programs to help women in the force.
@4QCM3LH6yrs6Y
women serve is Israel...look to them for information on how to utilize women in the armed forces
@44NDCMP6yrs6Y
Not if they are mothers and have small children at home, it is in my believe that a child needs his or her mother to raise them. They actually need both but most importantly the mother for nurturing them.
@4TR5DWK6yrs6Y
Let us look at the damage combat has done to men both physically and mentally. It destroyed them for any future civilian life. Our women do not deserve this, even if they might perform well under constant bombardment.
@4GYKCFB6yrs6Y
If men can decide to take up arms whether for their own personal economic reasons or their beliefs than women must be allowed and have the duty to take up arms as well. If women are allowed to vote they must be conscripted at the same rate as men. If a woman's ability on the battlefield in combat may make her more vulnerable than a man, and even a liability as well, this needs to be reflected in conscription at a higher rate of woman than men to compensate.
@B9LXNZC3mos3MO
It depends if the women would want to serve. in combat role, but the option must be available to them
@B89F54Q6mos6MO
Yes but increase physical standards drastically and only if the women can pass the same standards as the men.
@B4ZC8M51yr1Y
As long as they are just as capable as a man in combat and make the work environment safe from sexual assault from their colleagues
@B4VB3F31yr1Y
Yes as preventing women from serving in combat roles is discriminatory, as long as they can pass the same physical tests as men as many women on average are not as physically capable as men for combat, combat roles place women in a high risk situation for sexual assault and women must be informed of this and consent to the risk, men are also more likely to risk the success of a mission in order to protect a women from danger and as such she cannot be allowed any preferential treatment as a rule
@B4PS5QV1yr1Y
I don't like the idea of woman dying in combat, because woman are precious and deserve to not be. scientifically speaking woman are less strong and fast as a man so if it comes down to hand to hand combat, the woman is not black widow or wonder woman she will get destroyed by a military trained man. So my answer is no.
@B3G3R7S1yr1Y
Yes, if women are trained and prepared appropriately and have the strength, endurance and capacity to do the job involved in combat. It is a personal choice and also the ability to do the job. If an assault does occur it should be supported regardless if it happens to men or women.
@B7MX7CR7mos7MO
No, men are more suited and have had this responsibility for eons. And it would tend to put women at risk of sexual assault, if not from fellow soldiers, then when captured by the enemy. Also, after a devastating war, women are essential to re-growing the population.
@B54CHGM1yr1Y
Unless things get really bad with the rate of soilders dying women should not go into combat rules unless they complete the physical roles as men
@9YK7T9B1yr1Y
Not allowing women to serve is discrimination, but the military right now is rife with sexual violence and that is a more pressing concern
@9VZWW2H2yrs2Y
I think that women should have the option, but just like everyone, they need to understand the risks and be prepared to be treated the same when it comes to serving our country
@9656D9T4yrs4Y
i believe with the right amount of training a women should be allowed to serve in combat
@9JWZHWW2yrs2Y
Yes, but we shouldn't get ourselves involved in anything that would result in combat situations taking place.
@9GZYG4J2yrs2Y
No, unless that involve piloting robotic unmanned devices where women would be more likely suited than men for the task require for such position.
@9FM9QN93yrs3Y
Yes, as long as they're worthy and qualified.
@9F5KMPV3yrs3Y
A person of any gender should be allowed to join the military if they want. Not hiring based on gender is discrimination.
@9D4V5MC3yrs3Y
Yes, they already do and have done for decades.
@96CJFM3New Democratic4yrs4Y
Gender should be irrelevant, and only the measurement of physical aptitude should be used.
@95BRPDN4yrs4Y
There should be more effort put into ensuring there are fewer combat rolls. This being said, women should be allowed to serve in combat rolls. Increased prevention of sexual assault should be put in place.
@9RQNPMR2yrs2Y
That decision should depend on the individual and their commanding officer. Those who know the situation at hand
@98S47973yrs3Y
Yes, as long as they can pass the same physical tests as men and because not giving woman a chance is being discriminative
@4TY2NWN6yrs6Y
no send them back to the kitchen
@9C63S733yrs3Y
I do not care what they do. their life not mine.
@95SJ7544yrs4Y
No because no one should be in the military
@9464RF94yrs4Y
@945L3BV4yrs4Y
Yes, combat roles should be judged based on performance and ability, not gender.
@9449HS34yrs4Y
If they are as competent as the men
@942SC4B4yrs4Y
We do not need a military for combat
@8XKT3BG4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as they can pass the same physical tests as men and that she is informed of the risk that it represent for her (Rape, Injury, Etc.). (the male must be punished if they touch in an inappropriate way and after kick out of the military).
@8WZ4NMB5yrs5Y
If they are well qualified for the job, why not
@8VH22SV5yrs5Y
Women and children should be protected.
@8V7LPJX5yrs5Y
I served with women who I trusted because they earned that right. If earned, YES
@8V23N8YNew Democratic5yrs5Y
I don't agree with military in general.
@8TZPR695yrs5Y
No, no one should serve in the military
@8TYV78F5yrs5Y
F the person that wrote some of these options, it's disgusting. Of course, they should be allowed. "Higher risk for sexual assault" only means "more rapists"
@8TXVXML5yrs5Y
No, it's dishonorable to hide behind a woman.
@8TWKYGX5yrs5Y
Yes, and stop sexism and sexual harassment
@8TW3T395yrs5Y
no i don’t support the military
Yes, as long as they can pass any test/evaluation needed in order to serve
@8TQTW27New Democratic5yrs5Y
Yes, but with the acknowledgement of the sad reality that women in combat roles will face dangers that men often don't
@8SDPH6Y5yrs5Y
No, women should be in the kitchen.
@8T2CVZS5yrs5Y
they shouldn't have roles like infantry because the military had to lower their expectations 3 times for women to be in the military
@8SCRSMG5yrs5Y
Yes but there should be a unisex standard of fitness
@8RLZ9JT5yrs5Y
Experience and skills are more important then sex.
@8QT9385Conservative5yrs5Y
Yes, as long as they can do the job as they should
@8QSJWV75yrs5Y
Yes, as long as they can pass the same physical tests as men but there should be programs in place that will protect them from sexual assault.
@8QDY7CX5yrs5Y
Yes as long as the can complete the required training to the same standard as everyone else.
@8PYQT8Q5yrs5Y
Preventing them from filling those roles is discriminatory, also women greatly benefit military operations.
No, but men shouldn't be allowed either
No I believe we shouldn’t even have the military.
@tofutofu5yrs5Y
Yes, otherwise it would be discrimination. However, sexual assault is a real issue that needs to be given attention.
@8NHT9HF6yrs6Y
Yes, if they choose to and have the training to do so, also put programs in place protect them from sexual assault from their coworkers
@8JDRVHP6yrs6Y
Yes, as long as they pass the required physical tests for the strength of the woman and/or tests to be able to complete the job task given
@8HT3B6K6yrs6Y
yes, and more should be done about the high risk of sexual assault for them
@8D8S5H26yrs6Y
As long as they can capably complete the missions and they agree to the risks
@8CM5QDJNew Democratic6yrs6Y
Yes, but there should be regulations to protect women from sexual assault, on top of awareness for men to not risk the success to protect a women from danger either and vice versa...
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, as long as they can pass the same physical and psychological tests as men. Also make these tests more difficult.
@9CCVGFR3yrs3Y
I do not care about the military
@9C7WYWV3yrs3Y
Depends on the what the woman wants
@9BCJ5ZT3yrs3Y
The military needs to be disbanded and restructured
@99F7DQZ3yrs3Y
Abolish the military and replace it with a people's army
@99B9Y7X3yrs3Y
Yes if a woman insists on it, and knows the special risks. Women are best in treating wounded, and doing a million other supportive tasks, also intelligence,as they can be super smart.
@98DXRC23yrs3Y
They could, because they’re equal to men. But realistically who in their right mind would want to serve a combat purpose period?!
@93BCGRF4yrs4Y
i dont support the military in general
@8VJ8ZRD5yrs5Y
Yes, as long as they pass all the requirements
@8VJ7P3X5yrs5Y
Yes as long as the test examines a man’s fitness
@8VHSYBT5yrs5Y
Yes, but sexual assault is a big thing that needs to be stopped.
@8VC9XFB5yrs5Y
Nobody should serve in a combat role. It is time to end all war!!!
@8V3TFD4New Democratic5yrs5Y
No, I don’t care about having more female war criminals
@93P92RN4yrs4Y
We don’t need an armed forces
@936KWVL4yrs4Y
In non-spec ops roles, sure
@92PQBJW4yrs4Y
Yes, everyone has the right and ability to live out die for their country.
@8VSLZ6P5yrs5Y
Women should be required to serve in combat roles equally to Men.
@8VRT2TJ5yrs5Y
There shouldn't be any military in general
@8VPZYZJ5yrs5Y
Yes, as long as ability is proven. For any gender.
@8VN29JT5yrs5Y
War is stupid and no man or woman should have to go into combat because our political leaders can not find a diplomatic solution.
@8VMXKNFNew Democratic5yrs5Y
Get rid of the military and use the funds for something actually meaningful.
@8VLHZMB5yrs5Y
If they want to they should be allowed. The choice should be their own - no one else's
@8VJNWNB5yrs5Y
No, a nation should not risk women's lives in combat
@8V4643B5yrs5Y
It’s not something I have an opinion on.
@9334YP34yrs4Y
Yes, but on a purely voluntary basis, only so long as they unmarried and childless, as long as they meet the same standards as men, and never in a commanding or leadership role.
@heatherdvdprincess4yrs4Y
Yes, preventing women from serving in combat roles is discriminatory, but they should still have to meet the same requirements, and should not be drafted into combat roles. They should also be offered free birth control to prevent problems from rape by enemies.
Deleted4yrs4Y
No, women should not be allowed to serve in the military at all
Deleted4yrs4Y
No, women should be completely banned from the military
@92ZN97M4yrs4Y
Yes, only if hey. want to. since women do not have the same physical structures as men
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.