Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Ideology:
Political party:
@8ZJPQNV3yrs3Y
Yes but no at the same time. yes because they are still people but are just suspects, but no because they were or are terrorism's.
Deleted3yrs3Y
No, they need to prove they have no terrorist ties and mean our country no harm before given any constitutional rights
@9248M563yrs3Y
only if proven innocent.
@8R2V4494yrs4Y
No; unless terrorist suspect resides in US
Deleted4yrs4Y
They are not U.S. citizens and do not have constitutional rights but they should be tried in military tribunals and not subject to torture
@8N485KS4yrs4Y
No, they should have rights from their own country
@8M28H5V4yrs4Y
I don’t think they should have constitutional rights, but torture is wrong.
@8MNJHTX4yrs4Y
Don’t know what this means either
@8MNYGHJ4yrs4Y
a person convicted of terrorism should be punished by the laws of the place they live and the country the crime was committed in
@gabehwkns4yrs4Y
An international human rights law should be established to address this
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@9334YP33yrs3Y
As non-citizens they should not be given any constitutional rights that only apply to citizens, but they should be retain any constitutional rights that apply to non-citizens to the same extent as domestic terrorism suspects would.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, but only after proper investigation and background checks, and they are found not guilty and/or if they passed the standards to have the rights.
@93ZVQ532yrs2Y
Yes, while on American soil.
@8VLZM3Z3yrs3Y
i dont really know anything about this topic to say yes or no
@heatherdvdprincess3yrs3Y
No, they are not U.S. citizens and do not have constitutional rights, but they should not be subject to torture. We should do what one successful info-getter did by befriending the prisoners, going on walks with them, and soon these soldiers who were trained to withstand torture were sharing secret info by accident.
@8CS4GM74yrs4Y
Human rights, yes. Constitutional rights, not necessarily. Any person should be given a fair trial and should not be held indefinitely in an extrajudicial fashion.
Deleted4yrs4Y
Foreign terrorists should be treated as enemy combatants.
@8DD853J4yrs4Y
They should be given human rights and treated fairly.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Just shoot the terrorists.
Deleted3yrs3Y
It depends on any circumstances. If someone is claimed to be a terrorist but there is no visible evidence to suggest that they have been conspiring a terrorist act, then they should have constitutional rights. If, however, they pose a significant threat to our country and have clear evidence of conspiring a terrorist act, they should not have constitutional rights.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, after proper investigation and background checks, just to be sure that the foreigner won't go destroying our country. But only if they are found not guilty and/or if they passed the standards to have the rights.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, but only if they are found not guilty and/or if they passed the standards to have the rights after proper investigation and background checks, and just ensure that the foreigner won't go destroying our country.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, but only after proper investigation and background checks, and if they are found not guilty and/or if they passed the standards to have the rights.
@558YLXV3yrs3Y
Foreign terrorism suspects should not be subject to unusual or cruel punishments; they should be held for a very short time, then be released or tried by an appropriate court (either by the US or the nation in which they were captured). No one should be held in indefinite incarceration with no recourse.
@4PRKPMG4yrs4Y
Assuming they're in captivity, yes. They are still terrorists and the extension of our constitutional rights should be revoked if necessary.
@8Q8RMYM4yrs4Y
Yes, until proven guilty even though they may not be citizens, they should be seen fairly unless proven to have ties with terrorist organizations.
@8QMD4XF4yrs4Y
If they are just suspects yes but if there is actual proof that they were apart of terrorism or participated in it then no.
@8F5MHGJ4yrs4Y
I would not say so given they aren't citizens, I think the government could keep a close eye on those individuals.
@8SJ2BTW4yrs4Y
Yes, unless they are actual terrorist
@92MDVFR3yrs3Y
How flexible is the term suspect? If government agencies find the alleged with incriminating contraband, then no, they shouldn't have extensive legal opportunities. They should be afforded a fair trial, but appeals should be eliminated. Also, the penalties should fit the crime.
@7SKBHSL4yrs4Y
No, if they're proven to be terrorists. if they're proven not to be, then yes
@8FSK5JG4yrs4Y
yes and no, They are not U.S citizens but should be treated as a human being. just because they are different doesn't mean they aren't human
@8ZZTH4H3yrs3Y
They should have no Constitutional rights intel they are proven not guilty.
@8ZK5Q3Q3yrs3Y
Yes, unless they were actually convicted of the crime, then no they shouldn't be given rights.
@8DDBV2C4yrs4Y
i need more information to form an opinion
@8LGHYLR4yrs4Y
Not unless they are proven innocent.
@BaylorBlum4yrs4Y
They should but they should e closely monitored
@8LSR6G34yrs4Y
Yes, but only if they are registered citizens of the U.S., and if not give them back to their country for their country to take care of them on their country grounds.
@8TVYZQL3yrs3Y
No, but they should be given human rights and treated fairly based on how much they are suspected of terrorism.
@3868DQW4yrs4Y
If they are in the United States, they should be. If they are in a foreign country, they should be given the rights of that country. We cannot force our laws outside of our jurisdiction and we need to work together with foreign governments to ensure both of our safety.
@7GVHRDR4yrs4Y
Yes, Constitutional rights are inherent human rights. There should be no difference
@85QWNPG4yrs4Y
No, they aren’t U.S. Citizens and don’t have constitutional rights, and if we were to make every criminal captured into one, it would become a leading incentive for terorrist groups.
@8BYVY6B4yrs4Y
Human rights apply to EVERYbody, therefore they should be treated equally like everyone else
@85QWNPG3yrs3Y
Yes, while not citizens, they should be given the bare minimum of geneva rights when under our custody, even abroad.
@8C9PN2M4yrs4Y
Basic human rights apply, but they are not US citizens
@8CQ7HBG4yrs4Y
They should be given a trial but they also should be tortured to get information.
@8558FRW3yrs3Y
No, but they should be treated humanely when possible.
@8CY5FJV4yrs4Y
Treat them like a human but they don't have rights as a citizen
@RickStewart3yrs3Y
When Congress declares war, the rules of war should apply to enemy combatants. Foreign terrorism suspects will evaporate when we stop fighting undeclared wars.
@8DPS4HQ4yrs4Y
I don't understand what this question is asking.
@8DN4WYN4yrs4Y
Yes we should set examples and not be like them. Coincidentally the war on terror has lasted 20 years...if no one other than me has noticed.
@8DNCRM74yrs4Y
it depends on if they are just being suspected/accused without rightful evidence or if they have actual evidence
@8DQKM4N4yrs4Y
Yes, if they are found to be innocent.
@8FC86NP4yrs4Y
If they are proven innocent then yes
@8FSLGMY4yrs4Y
I am young so I wouldn't accept or decline
@8FQVQFP4yrs4Y
although they have done wrong things, they should be given a chance since they are human and have rights. if they fail the second chance, take them into custody. in the end, they would be walking on very thin ice with america.
@riddlecongress4yrs4Y
No, they are not U.S. citizens and do not have constitutional rights. They should be treated as terrorist war criminals and held to the international standard in dealing with international criminals.
@8GKG6BP4yrs4Y
They should be treated as human beings, but have limited constitutional rights as they are not citizens.
@8GJ3NJZ4yrs4Y
Suspects must be given a fair trial until found guilty to prevent harming the wrongly accused.
@8GJ3NJZ4yrs4Y
Suspects must be given a fair trial until found guilty to prevent harming wrongly accused.
@2020AaronJames4yrs4Y
Our constitutional rights exists because that is how we believe human beings should be treated.
@8GPJ7R74yrs4Y
No, they are not U.S. citizens but basic human rights are still valid.
@8GSRY4T4yrs4Y
No I don't think so, if they are suspected why take the chance
@8HG2T3K4yrs4Y
@8HCSLFD4yrs4Y
If they are legal citizens yes, if they aren't then no.
@8HJ4B4M4yrs4Y
If they are not a citizen they should not be given constitutional rights but as a human being they should not be tortured or treated as a animal.
@8HJXS4T4yrs4Y
I DON'T KNOW if they were only suspected because of their nationality then yeah, give them their rights! But like if there was a legit reason then Idk be just a little cautious? not racist! Cautious.
@8HTZGH74yrs4Y
Until they are proven to be terrorists, they should be treated equally like all other people.
@8JFQYRZ4yrs4Y
They should be tried civilly or at the very least not tortured unless they have information that they are not willing to give up that could save lives but in moderation.
@8JNGTQF4yrs4Y
everyone deserves free trail before being accused of any thing ,no matter what it is.
@8JK96GY4yrs4Y
It depends on what they've been suspected of so maybe but maybe not.
@8JMVLDF4yrs4Y
They should be tried in Military Tribunals but not subject to torture, unless required.
@8JPLPJ24yrs4Y
Give them a fair trial and they should still be protected under constitutional rights(that are applicable) however they should not be subjected to torture.
@8JRC8XB4yrs4Y
No not constitutional rights but basic human rights.
@8JWX9SX4yrs4Y
If they are in America or somewhere where our constitutional rights are in effect, they should have constitutional rights
@8KCZFTR4yrs4Y
Not if they do not have citizenship or are not planning to become a citizen
@8KLLCKT4yrs4Y
They should still have their basic human rights, if we’re going to be the ones putting them to justice it should at least be by our own rules.
@8L2DQDJ4yrs4Y
No unless they’re proven innocent or served enough time
@8LCBSBP4yrs4Y
It depends what we think they are going to do.
@8LJ78V94yrs4Y
No, they should not be given constitutional rights but they should not be subject to torture at the hands of the government or military.
@8LJD4FT4yrs4Y
Yes, give them a fair trial like they are a citizen
@8LZKM6T4yrs4Y
They should be held accountable as war prisoners and treated as such. UCMJ.
@8M9RLHZ4yrs4Y
Depends, but Guatanamo Bay should be shut down.
@8MR6SHM4yrs4Y
No, because if they are a suspect of murdering people or planning anything, they should be sent right to prison.
@8MW5FBX4yrs4Y
Yes, though not equivalent to U.S. citizens, they deserve a fair and impartial trial.
@8MZ79MJ4yrs4Y
@8NRNL6B4yrs4Y
Yes they should be able to have rights. Just limited rights because they aren´t citzens.
@8NXSCW24yrs4Y
Yes, if they are established U.S citizens or are already in the process of establishing citizenship.
Join in on more popular conversations.